|
| hornet |
|
|||
|
I'm just wondering what the implications would be in running a big cam (Wade 1521a or Crow Stg 3) without a chip. I will be getting a Unichip in the future, but want to do the mods piece by piece as finances permit.
I guess the idle would be affected, but are there any other problems?
_________________ 5 Speed EL Futura
|
|||
| Top | |
|||
| Muffy |
|
||
|
The car should still idle, it will just sound lumpy as f**k, and may stall occasionaly, depending on the valve overlap times. I have done some cams on an ed 4.0l, crowcam stage 3, and had it chipped the next day, ran realy rough and was irritating to drive under 2500rpm, kept hesitating. I can't imagine driving it for a couple of months. Fuel economy wouldn't be to good.
Or you can chip now and cam later. Or just save and do it all at the same time. |
||
| Top | |
||
| Muffy |
|
||
|
The car should still idle, it will just sound lumpy as f**k, and may stall occasionaly, depending on the valve overlap times. I have done some cams on an ed 4.0l, crowcam stage 3, and had it chipped the next day, ran realy rough and was irritating to drive under 2500rpm, kept hesitating. I can't imagine driving it for a couple of months. Fuel economy wouldn't be to good.
Or you can chip now and cam later. Or just save and do it all at the same time. |
||
| Top | |
||
| hornet |
|
|||
|
Muffy wrote: The car should still idle, it will just sound lumpy as f**k
That sounds good! mmmm lumpy *drool* I thought fuel economy would be affected, the car isn't a daily driver, I have a bike and a work car for that  the chip is a unichip, so its not really an option to get it first. Getting it all at once would make sence, but i'm impatient and want the cam NOW! 
_________________ 5 Speed EL Futura
|
|||
| Top | |
|||
| NC Steve |
|
|||
|
I am running a 1521A with a stock ECU. It doesn't idle at all on petrol (duel fuel) and it runs very very rich, so if you care about your fuel economy.... The engine is useless below around 2000-2500rpm so be prepared to keep the revs up.
|
|||
| Top | |
|||
| hornet |
|
|||
|
NC Steve wrote: I am running a 1521A with a stock ECU. It doesn't idle at all on petrol (duel fuel) and it runs very very rich, so if you care about your fuel economy.... The engine is useless below around 2000-2500rpm so be prepared to keep the revs up.
Fuel consumption isn't a huge issue as its only a weekend car at the moment. (trying to get a new BA out of work as a new company car) Keep the revs above 2000-2500 rpm, now problemo  5 speeds help for that
_________________ 5 Speed EL Futura
|
|||
| Top | |
|||
| drazull |
|
||
|
I would unichip first and cam second. Just get the chip reprogrammed once the cams in.
A big cam will make the car slower, give poor fuel economy and big flat spots. By bad idle, you do understand this to be allmost on the verge of constantly stalling dont you? That aint cool. Biggest cams would be best left last.
_________________ Not lost any demerit points |
||
| Top | |
||
| uglybob |
|
|||
|
drazull wrote: By bad idle, you do understand this to be allmost on the verge of constantly stalling dont you? That aint cool.
agreed. my mate put a stg 3 crow cam in his EF - ok-ish whilst actually driving, but starting/stopping/idling at lights etc - just stupid - could not idle at all - just something to consider!
_________________ R.I.P. Scotty |
|||
| Top | |
|||
| 4.9 EF Futura |
|
|||
|
Lol, i wish we could get a sound clip of walkinshaw's monty. The idle on that thing is crazy... it literally sounds like someone is sitting in the car, revving the thing over and over and over. Theres a good 2500 hunt...
I think extra timing advance at idle is the trick to smoothen the 6bangers out?
_________________ I promise..... I will never die. |
|||
| Top | |
|||
| uglybob |
|
|||
|
4.9 EF Futura wrote: I think extra timing advance at idle is the trick to smoothen the 6bangers out?
assuming you mean bumping up the base idle martin? if so - that only works to a point. my stg 2 crow will hold idle ~800 - 850rpm - even then, its still not great. a stage 3 - you'd have to be pushing the base idle to around 1000rpm to hold idle - which is far too high  the smaller cams respond better to an improved base idle, but the stg 3 onwards have some serious issues with holding anything resembling an idle.
_________________ R.I.P. Scotty |
|||
| Top | |
|||
| 4.9 EF Futura |
|
|||
|
Nah sorry fraser - crappy response on my behalf... i was referring to the tuning side of things... i.e. why a unichip/other ECU mod is the go... as i believe the trick is to advance timing to smoothen the idle...
_________________ I promise..... I will never die. |
|||
| Top | |
|||
| bradders |
|
|||
|
Could you install a crow cam stage 3 and then get it dyno tuned instead of getting it chipped would that resolve the poor idle and fuel economy?
_________________ PH 4480 racing extractors
|
|||
| Top | |
|||
| drazull |
|
||
|
possibly but still not the ideal way to go about getting it to idle right.
Big cams require a chip. If you want a big cam and no chip then the dev 3HL is the only option.
_________________ Not lost any demerit points |
||
| Top | |
||
| loxxr6 |
|
|||
|
Quote: I would unichip first and cam second. Just get the chip reprogrammed once the cams in.
Sounds like its the expensive way to go.Just wait til you can get it all done in one hit. Save yourself the second retune of the Unichip. If it's any comparison I had the dev5 in my manual au xr6 and it ran fine. No stalling or bad behaviour at all. I have no experience however with how the Crow cams are though. |
|||
| Top | |
|||
| Mako |
|
||
|
bradders wrote: Could you install a crow cam stage 3 and then get it dyno tuned instead of getting it chipped would that resolve the poor idle and fuel economy?
Short answer no... even wacking the car on the dyno, what do you tune? you cant tune the standard ecu without a chip. a dyno tune on a standard ecu really means SFA 
_________________ Regency Red EL Fairmont - PH4480 - 2.5" exhaust - High flow cat/muffler - K&N panel filter - Mandrel bent air intake - T series intake - wade 1604 cam - 98 EL XR6 ECU - Whiteline lows - 17" ROH RT's - Koni yellows - DBA Slotted's - Green Stuff pads
|
||
| Top | |
||
| Who is online |
|---|
Users browsing this forum: Google Adsense [Bot] and 44 guests |
